Historic Preservation & Building History
The Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Dubuque’s Building Story
The German Methodist Episcopal Church at 1699 Iowa Street was built in 1885 for $6,000. The style is Carpenter Gothic, featuring a gabled (triangled) roof, arched windows, wainscoting, and trim, which became available with the scroll saw. It is a “pattern book” building based on architectural designs and drawings made available to Methodist congregations through the denomination. Although many buildings were built in this style, especially in the East and Midwest, most have been destroyed. The building is the only Carpenter Gothic church in Dubuque.
The German Methodist Episcopal Church, established in 1843, relocated three times before constructing its current building in the German-speaking district of the town. In 1918, when the country was at war with Germany, the word “German” was chiseled out of the cornerstone on the northeast side of the building and replaced with “Grace.”
In 1965, Grace Methodist Episcopal Church members joined St. Luke’s Methodist Church and sold the property to the Assembly of God Church. Grace Bible Baptist Church purchased the building in 1983 and sold it to us, the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Dubuque, in 2004. The UU Fellowship, established in 1984, initially rented meeting spaces before acquiring this property that met our requirements.
Historic Preservation
In 2020, John and Alice Butler, friends of the Fellowship for a decade and philanthropists who appreciate historic Dubuque architecture, offered a two-for-one match for funds raised by the congregation to completely rehabilitate the church by restoring the main floor, the exterior of the building, and along with the exterior of the adjacent parsonage (built in 1915). The rehabilitation funding in the main building included modernizing the basement plus adding a lift.
The Fellowship’s 65 members and friends raised over $250,000 through donations and grants, with an additional $495,000 earned in State Historic Tax Credits. The Fellowship contracted with Heritage Works, Inc., Dubuque, to apply for grants and tax credits, and ensure compliance with funding requirements. Gronen Development and Restoration, Dubuque, served as the General Contractor for the project, ensuring that the rehabilitation met historic preservation standards. Stickley Morton Architects created plans to restore and preserve the building’s past, and accommodate the current and future space needs of the congregation. Groundbreaking was in 2021, the church restoration was completed in 2022, and the parsonage (Emerson House) restoration was completed in 2023.
Grants were awarded from the National Trust for Historic Preservation (Cynthia Woods Mitchell Fund) for ceiling restoration; Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs (window restoration), Iowa Department of Administrative Services (storm windows), City of Dubuque Façade Grant Program, City of Dubuque Dubuque Arts and Culture Special Projects Grant, and MidAmerica UU Region Chalice Lighters Grant.
The $2.1 million project included:
- Belfry replication: The original belfry, after some deterioration, was removed in the mid-1970s. The new one was created by Rob Droessler Construction, Hazel Green, Wisconsin.
- Church structural restoration: The foundation in the northeast corner under the belfry was rebuilt with steel. Support was given to the walls, floor joists, and beams. Cedar wood shingles were installed.
- Interior restoration: The drop ceilings were removed, revealing vaulted ceilings and original artwork in the East Wing, which was restored by professionals. Circular and pointed arch windows were restored, and a lift was installed for wheelchair accessibility between the main level and Fellowship Hall. The restrooms on each floor have been made accessible for individuals using wheelchairs.
The building has received historic preservation awards from the City of Dubuque Historic Preservation Commission, County Historic Commission, and Preservation Iowa.
In the News
- Fellowship of the roof, By Chrystine Elle Hanus, November 2025
- August 14, 2024: Heritage Works Dubuque: Anthony “Tony” Kartsonas of Historic Surfaces LLC, recently visited Dubuque to restore the decorative Trompe-l’œil ceiling that was uncovered during the rehabilitation of the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Dubuque. Tony is a historic finishes and material conservation expert who was worked on many high-profile projects throughout the country.
- May 2nd, 2023, will be a day of celebration – as we will receive two Historic Preservation Awards that evening: one from the City of Dubuque Historic Preservation Commission and one from the Dubuque County Historic Preservation Commission in conjunction with the Dubuque County Historical Society. Our UU Fellowship and our project partners have been chosen as one of the recipients of the 2023 Ken Kringle Historic Preservation Commission Awards! The award is for the best preservation and rehabilitation projects in the City of Dubuque. It is named after the late Ken Kringle, for his dedication to historic preservation through involvement with the Historic Preservation Commission, Bluff Street Neighborhood Association, and Old House Enthusiasts Club.
- Dubuque church renovation uncovers another historic treasure, Telegraph Herald, June 25, 2022
- Unexpected discovery: 136-year-old time capsule unearthed during Dubuque church project, Telegraph Herald, Nov 27, 2021
- Dubuque church restoration project gives whole neighborhood a lift, Telegraph Herald, Jan 8, 2021
- Unitarian congregation raises $215,000 toward restoration, Telegraph Herald, Jan 4, 2021
- Heritage Works Community Benefit Project: The Unitarian Universalist Fellowship project, Heritage Works Year-End 2020 Newsletter